Hagada Hasmalit

a critical review of israeli culture and society

Posted by רני On November - 13 - 2007 0 Comment

It’s become almost impossible to say anything about Jews, even as a mild joke. An African-American actress jokes about a photo showing her with a big nose (“That’s my Jewish cousin”), and all hell breaks loose. She apologizes for the “antisemitic” remark and eats humble pie.

What if a Jewish actress quipped about a photo showing her looking bronzed, that it was her “African-American cousin”, would she have had to to apologize? – Unlikely, and nor should she have. But the general public has been warned never to refer to Jews at all, except in a flattering way.
It goes much further than that, of course. The mildest criticism of Israel provokes a vicious response. Any other country may be criticised and some more than most – compare how events in Georgia and Venezuela are reported in the mainstream Western press – but Israel must never be described as anything other than a decent, brave, clever, generous little democracy, constantly threatened with annihilation by its bloodthirsty Muslim Arab neighbors.
In many countries it is illegal to deny the Holocaust, and in some countries you can go to jail for doing so. On the other hand, it’s all right to deny the catastrophe that the State of Israel has wreaked in the Middle East. It is legal to persecute and hound critics of Israel and the Zionist lobby, or anyone who presumes to mention the suffering of the Palestinians. And of course it’s open season on Islam – unlike any other religion, you are free to vilify it in the ugliest terms.
* * *
But it is not antisemitism to criticize Israel. It is not “self-hate” to do so if you’re a Jew. On the contrary – blind support for Israel equals anti-Arabism, anti-Islam, racism pure and simple. Those who blindly support Zionism, and its political creation Israel, are guilty of racism which is really anti-Semitic – the Arab people are as Semitic as the Jews and far more numerous. How else is it possible to justify what is actually going on in the Middle East? – A nation of five or six million dominating five to six million others, expropriating their lands and homes, denying them all rights – human, civil or national – subjecting them to constant violence, killing them with impunity, holding thousands of them in prison without trial; intimidating the neighboring countries with overflights and periodic military attacks; building up an immense arsenal of weapons of mass destruction, yet forcibly preventing any other state in the region from even beginning to approach the possibility of developing them; running a state as a quasi-theocracy – religion being the one qualifier for citizenship and full civil rights, and rabbis holding parliamentary and government positions – while decrying the neighboring Muslim states as “fundamentalist”.
I, an Israeli born and bred (born, I should add, in Palestine well before the establishment of the State of Israel, to which my parents devoted their lives), refuse to be tagged as a “self-hating Jew”, refuse to accept the sacrosanct status of the people I was born into and the government which claims to represent me. I cannot close my eyes to the evils of Zionist colonialism, the non-democratic practices of the Israeli social system, which gives full rights to some citizens and denies them to others on an “ethnic”/religious basis, the role it plays in destabilizing the region and keeping it always on the verge of war – which it always wins, being militarily far stronger than all its neighbors combined. I refuse to endorse the use of the Holocaust as a propaganda weapon by a regime that has exploited it in the form of reparations (from post-war Germany) and guilt-offerings from the Allied governments – yet has never allowed Holocaust survivors to hold senior positions in its government and marginalized them socially.
It should be perfectly legitimate to criticize Israel. Giving it uncritical, unqualified support in all its actions, its violations of dozens of UN Security Council resolutions, its policy of assassination and destruction – that is a racist position, a position that says “Arabs don’t count, Arabs have no rights, Arabs are vermin and whatever is done to them – in Palestine, Syria, Iraq or Lebanon – is legitimate. And Islam is the same as Fascism.”
Now that is real anti-Semitism.

Categories: The Left and Protest

No Responses

  1. Paul says:

    You’re not a self-hating Jew, you’re an antisemite. Just because you’re Jewish does not mean you have license to make bigotted comments and then pretend you’re being attacked when someone complains. Who knows what would have happened if a Jewish actress made a black joke?

    I remember Don Imus said Howard Kurtz was a boner nosed money grubbing jew. He didn’t get kicked off the air. Yet when he said the deplorable, “nappy-headed hoe” comment, he was. Doesn’t mean there’s a black media conspiracy. There isn’t a Jewish one either.

  2. Patricia J. Barry says:

    I am not certain what the above comment is about. However, as an American citizen whose tax dollars fund a state — Israel — who daily violates the civil and human rights of Palestinians after stealing their land, I have a duty and right to speak out against such misuse of MY tax dollars. Those who scream at, attack, and harass those who make such criticism of a state which violates basic human rights of another group of people are, to put it simply, irrational. Irrational because we live in a country which gives at least lip service to the First Amendment’s guarantee of free speech, especially speech addressing political issues. So, to engage in ad feminam and ad hominem attacks against those who make up the rising chorus of voices speaking out against Israeli atrocities against the Palestinians is, in effect, to say that the First Amendment applies only to a precious few, when it must, by logic, apply to all, especially to those who seek peaceful change in foreign and domestic policy. Irrational because such vitriolic attacks are made by individuals hiding behind the violation of the Jews’ civil and human rights for centuries by Europeans and to some extent, by the U. S. For example, it is well documented that the U. S. State Dept would not assist Jews trying to escape Hitler’s tyranny just before WWII causing many of those Jews to perish. Human and civil rights apply to ALL OF US, not just a selected few. We must engage in dialog, not in a diatribe.

Leave a Reply

Featured Posts

Gaza is not Bagdad – Yet

Both within the ranks of Hamas and Fatah, there are hot headed trigger happy adventurists ...